Non-discretionary PMS is a portfolio management service where the portfolio manager provides recommendations but cannot execute any transaction without the investor's approval.
Portfolio Management Services (PMS) gives you a more customised approach than regular investment products. Yet not every investor wants to hand over all decision making authority.
In a non-discretionary setup, the manager supplies research and portfolio insights. The investor gets recommendations. They review each suggested move and decide whether to execute. This service appeals to those who value professional guidance and also want to stay actively involved in their own portfolio decisions.
Key Takeaways
- A portfolio manager recommends trades, but you retain the final power to accept or reject them.
- The Securities and Exchange Board of India SEBI sets a minimum capital requirement of ₹50 lakh for starting this investment service.
- All stocks and securities stay directly in your demat account under your permanent account number.
- Returns depend on market movements and how quickly you approve proposed portfolio trades.
What Is Non-Discretionary PMS?
Non-discretionary Portfolio Management Services (PMS) is a specialised investment management service where a licensed portfolio manager provides research, strategy, and recommendations, while the investor retains complete authority over all buy and sell decisions.
Under this arrangement, you hire a portfolio manager to continuously monitor the markets, analyze financial statements, and identify potential opportunities across equities, debt, or other securities. The manager functions strictly as an advisor and execution partner, tailoring detailed trade proposals to your specific financial goals and risk profile.
Crucially, the manager cannot buy or sell a single security independently. Once they share an investment proposal, you evaluate the underlying research and risk profile. The manager executes the transaction through your broker account only after receiving your explicit, formal consent.
For example, if the manager identifies a promising opportunity in a large-cap Indian stock, they present the investment thesis and risk factors to you. You then make the final call on whether or not to execute the trade.
How Does Non-Discretionary PMS Work?
Understanding what non-discretionary portfolio management is in daily practice involves a three-step operational sequence between you and your appointed asset manager.
Step 1: Portfolio Manager Analyses Investments
Portfolio managers study securities and market conditions. The client’s investment objectives also get their attention. The analysis may include financial performance, valuation, sector outlook, and portfolio exposure.
Step 2: Recommendations Are Shared
The portfolio manager uses the analysis to present a recommendation to clients, specifying the target company, recommended price limit, share allocation, exact rationale behind the entry or exit.
Step 3: Investor Approves the Transaction
The investor then reviews each specific recommendation and decides whether to proceed. Trades are executed strictly and only after receiving explicit client authorization. If the investor gives their formal approval through the agreed channel, the transaction executes under the agreed PMS arrangement.
Also Read About:Portfolio Management Services Vs Mutual Funds
Features of Non-Discretionary PMS
Operating a non discretionary portfolio management account comes with several distinct operational features:
- Pre-Authorization Trade Execution: Every individual buy or sell transaction strictly requires explicit prior client approval before the trade is executed.
- Customized Mandate Setup: Account parameters are structured around specific client criteria, including liquidity needs, existing stock holdings, tax profiles, and investment restrictions.
- Direct Depository Visibility: Investors retain direct login access to their Depository Participant (DP) account to monitor real-time holdings, verified trade confirmations, and corporate actions.
- Formal Advisory Routing: Investment recommendations are delivered alongside detailed trade rationale, target price limits, and proposed allocations before order placement.
Also Read About: Selecting a good Portfolio Management Service
Benefits of Non-Discretionary PMS
Non-discretionary PMS can suit investors who want expert support without completely handing over portfolio decisions.
- You get professional market research: You get access to institutional valuation models and corporate earnings evaluations. This access spares you from spending hours screening annual reports.
- You have total asset control: You retain the veto power over every buy and sell order. This prevents unwanted trades from taking place.
- You get tailored investment strategies: your manager designs a portfolio structure that suits your preferences, such as removing specific sectors or high debt firms.
- You get ongoing portfolio monitoring: The management team tracks corporate developments and quarterly earnings. They keep an eye on macro changes.
- Enhanced Transparency & Direct Participation (vs. Discretionary PMS): Unlike discretionary PMS where the fund manager trades autonomously, this structure offers total transparency into every transaction before execution, allowing investors to actively participate in strategic decision-making and gain deeper insight into the underlying trade rationale.
Limitations of Non-Discretionary PMS
Non-discretionary PMS also places more responsibility on the investor.
- Fast moving share prices can slip past recommended levels. This happens if you do not confirm trade requests promptly.
- You must regularly evaluate proposals and study manager notes to keep the strategy active.
- Holding final veto rights means poor choices and rejected sound ideas affect your net returns.
- Equities carry standard volatility. Professional research cannot guarantee profits. Nor can it protect against broad market falls.
- Delays in reviewing and approving recommendations introduce significant opportunity cost, as missed timing can cause you to miss favorable entry or exit points, execute trades at less advantageous prices, or completely forfeit high-potential market opportunities.
Non-Discretionary PMS vs Discretionary PMS
The table below shows difference between non discretionary portfolio management and the discretionary model across core parameters:
| Factor | Non-Discretionary PMS | Discretionary PMS |
| Decision making | Investor makes the final decision | Portfolio manager makes investment decisions |
| Investor involvement | Higher | Lower |
| Trade Execution Approval | Requires explicit client approval before every trade execution | No prior approval required; manager executes trades autonomously |
| Portfolio manager role | Researches and recommends | Researches and manages |
| Investor control | Greater | More limited in day to day decisions |
| Suitable for | Investors wanting professional input with control | Investors preferring professional management with less involvement |
Who Should Consider Non-Discretionary PMS?
Non-discretionary PMS can suit investors with substantial capital. They understand market risks but they do not want to do all their own investment research.
This arrangement can work well for someone who wants professional analysis. Yet that person still prefers to decide which recommendations actually enter the portfolio. The investor should also have the time and willingness to review each proposal.
Conversely, investors seeking complete delegation, hands-off management, and minimal involvement in day-to-day trading decisions may find non-discretionary PMS unsuited to their needs and may prefer discretionary PMS instead.
Under SEBI's current rules, PMS generally requires a minimum investment of ₹50 lakh.
That requirement does not apply to accredited investors, though subject to applicable conditions and disclosures.
Also Read About:Types of Risk in the Stock Market
SEBI Regulations Governing Non-Discretionary PMS
Non-discretionary PMS falls under SEBI's Portfolio Managers Regulations 2020. Several key requirements and safeguards apply.
SEBI also insists every portfolio manager must register with the regulator. Without registration no one can offer PMS. The standard minimum investment is ₹50 lakh. Accredited investors may qualify for an exemption from that.
A client agreement is mandatory. That agreement must spell out specific investment objectives, services, restrictions, risks, fees, and other terms. Investors receive full disclosures about the PMS and its risks and charges.
Managers cannot promise or guarantee returns. They also owe a fiduciary duty to clients. That duty requires them to act in a fiduciary capacity concerning the client funds.
Under SEBI guidelines, Non Discretionary Portfolio Management Service allows
to allocate up to 25% of a client’s AUM in unlisted securities, a flexibility not extended to discretionary PMS. Because non-discretionary clients retain final approval authority over every transaction, SEBI allows this allocation under the premise that investors can independently evaluate the higher illiquidity and valuation risks associated with unlisted assets before providing written consent.
Conclusion
Non-discretionary PMS gives you institutional research alongside personal autonomy. You get stock recommendations and macro analysis. Yet you keep full authority over each transaction. Investors who want dedicated research support without handing over trade decisions will find this structure offers balanced portfolio management.
Looking to invest?Open a Demat Account with Angel One and start trading seamlessly.
