Shares in a company can be represented by various legal instruments, each having a unique purpose in acknowledging or facilitating ownership. Share certificates and warrants are two such instruments that are frequently discussed in terms of corporate structure and capital management. While both deal with shares, they differ in how ownership is registered, exercised, and transferred. This article will guide you about the nature of share certificates and share warrants, how they work inside a company, and the fundamental difference between share certificate and share warrant in terms of legal status, rights, and practical use.
(Note: Under the Companies Act, 2013, the issuance of new share warrants by public companies is prohibited in India to ensure transparency and curb money laundering. Existing warrants issued under the previous Act were mandated to be surrendered and converted into Demat shares.)
Key Takeaways
-
Share certificates provide voting and dividend rights immediately upon registration.
-
Share certificates are mandatory for shareholders (unless held in Demat), whereas share warrants are bearer instruments that are no longer permitted for new issuance.
-
The transfer and ownership rights of the two instruments differ significantly.
-
To exercise shareholder rights, share warrants must first be converted into registered shares.
What is Share Certificate?
A share certificate is a statutory legal document issued by a company that confirms that an individual or entity owns a specific number of shares. It serves as conclusive evidence of share ownership and includes key information such as the shareholder's name, folio number, class of shares, number of shares owned, certificate number, and date of issuance. Companies in India are required by law to issue share certificates within certain time frames under the Companies Act of 2013, unless the shares are held in Demat form.
The certificate serves as tangible or documented evidence of ownership, and the shareholder's name is recorded in the company's membership register. This registration allows the shareholder to exercise their statutory rights, such as voting at general meetings, receiving dividends, and participating in corporate activities, such as bonus or rights offerings. The transfer of physical shares represented by a share certificate requires the completion of a legal transfer deed and approval by the company.
What is Share Warrant?
A share warrant is a negotiable document issued by a company that grants the bearer (holder) the right to buy shares or represents an interest in shares without registering the holder's name in the company's register of members. Unlike registered shares, a share warrant is granted to the bearer; therefore, possession of the instrument is the basis of claim rather than official registration.
Regulatory Warning: The issuance of share warrants is prohibited under the Companies Act, 2013. A recent Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) notification mandated that all outstanding share warrants issued prior to 2013 be surrendered and converted into Demat shares by 2024.
A share warrant operates by permitting the transfer of interest by mere delivery, eliminating the procedural requirements that apply to share transfers. However, the holder of a share warrant does not have membership rights, including voting or dividend rights, until the warrant is surrendered and converted into shares. Upon conversion, the holder's name is recorded in the membership register, and a share certificate (or Demat credit) is issued.
Read More: Understanding Stock Warrants
Key Differences Between Share Certificate and Share Warrant
The main difference between a share certificate and a share warrant is how ownership is acknowledged, rights are exercised, and transfers are carried out. Here's a table outlining the differences between the two:
|
Basis of Comparison |
Share Certificate |
Share Warrant |
|
Nature |
Documentary evidence of registered share ownership. |
Negotiable instrument representing bearer entitlement to shares. |
|
Legal status |
Conclusive legal proof of ownership. |
Limited legal recognition until conversion; banned for new issuance. |
|
Holder identity |
Shareholder’s name recorded in register of members. |
Holder’s name not recorded (Anonymous). |
|
Issuance requirement |
Mandatory on allotment or transfer of shares. |
Prohibited under Companies Act, 2013. |
|
Transfer process |
Requires transfer deed and company approval. |
Transferable by mere delivery. |
|
Shareholder rights |
Full rights with voting and dividends. |
Rights are available only after conversion. |
|
Applicability in India |
Commonly used and legally recognised. |
Phased out/Extinguished due to regulatory mandates. |
|
Risk of loss |
Can be replaced if lost or damaged. |
High risk; loss of document usually means loss of ownership. |
|
Dematerialisation |
Can exist in demat or physical form. |
Must be converted to Demat shares to be valid. |
Also Read: Market Capitalization vs. Equity
Practical Applications of Share Certificate and Share Warrant
Share certificates and share warrants are utilised in many business and investment situations, depending on the level of ownership control and regulatory compliance needed. Their application is determined by how companies arrange their shareholdings and manage capital.
Use of share certificates in practice
Share certificates are generally used to determine and record the legal ownership of shares. They are used in the following scenarios:
-
Maintaining statutory records of shareholders under the company legislation.
-
Allowing shareholders to utilise their voting rights at general meetings.
-
Facilitating dividend distribution and engagement in corporate activities.
-
Supporting share transfers, pledges, and planning for succession.
Use of share warrants in practice
Historically, share warrants were used when flexibility prevailed above formal ownership. However, due to the risk of anonymity being used for illicit purposes, they have been discontinued. In modern investment contexts, "Stock Warrants" (options to buy shares later) exist, but the traditional "Bearer Share Warrant" is obsolete in India.
In investment contexts, share certificates are suitable for long-term ownership and governance involvement, whereas share warrants are connected with niche arrangements requiring ease of transfer and conditional rights.
Also Read: Types of Shares
Advantages and Disadvantages of Share Certificate and Share Warrant
Share certificates and share warrants offer distinct advantages and disadvantages based on the ownership structure, legal constraints, and amount of control desired by investors.
Share Certificate: Pros and Cons
|
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
|
Gives clear legal proof of share ownership |
The transfer process involves formal documents. |
|
Enables full shareholder rights. |
Physical certifications pose the risk of loss or damage. |
|
Ensures transparency through registration in the company records. |
Replacement may necessitate procedural compliance. |
|
Widely acknowledged under Indian company law. |
Less flexibility than bearer instruments. |
Share Warrant: Pros and Cons
|
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
|
Easy transferability via delivery |
Holder is not considered a registered shareholder. |
|
Allows the holder to remain anonymous. |
No voting or dividend rights until conversion |
|
Useful in specialised or conditional financing structures |
Higher risk in case of loss or theft |
|
Reduces administrative formalities for transfer |
Due to regulatory constraints, it is rarely utilised. |
Conclusion
Share certificates and share warrants serve unique purposes in corporate shareholding, catering to different operational and investment requirements. Thus, understanding the difference between a share certificate and a share warrant becomes crucial in identifying how share ownership and rights are structured within a company.
Share certificate serves as a formal record, guaranteeing legal recognition and long-term accountability to shareholders. Share warrant, on the other hand, offers a more flexible method of transferring share rights and are commonly employed in specialised finance or short-term/temporary agreements.
Recognising each instrument's actual uses, dangers, and limits enables investors and businesses to make more educated decisions about ownership documentation, capital management, and corporate regulatory compliance. This transparency is critical for sound business governance and investment planning.
