Carbonated Juices to Attract 12% GST After High Court Ruling

In a landmark decision, the Gauhati High Court ruled that fruit pulp and juice-based carbonated drinks, including those by X’SS Beverage, should be taxed at 12% GST instead of the higher 28%. This ruling comes as a relief to manufacturers producing such drinks, as it recognises the essential nature of fruit juice in these products rather than categorising them purely as carbonated beverages.

Legal Basis for the Decision

The court’s decision was based on the Rules for Interpretation of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, which provides guidelines on how goods should be classified for taxation purposes. According to these rules, when a product does not neatly fit into a single category, it should be classified according to its essential character.

The high court determined that fruit pulp and juice-based carbonated drinks derive their core identity from their fruit juice content rather than their carbonation, thereby making them eligible for the lower GST slab. The court also considered scientific studies and past rulings, including the case of Parle’s ‘Appy Fizz,’ to support its decision.

Arguments from GST Authorities and Manufacturers

The GST authorities had previously contended that carbonated fruit drinks should be classified under the same category as soft drinks, which attract a higher tax rate. Their argument was based on the presence of carbonated water in these beverages, which, under their interpretation, placed them in the higher 28% GST category.

On the other hand, manufacturers maintained that the predominant ingredient in their beverages was fruit juice, which influenced the product’s essential nature. They argued that these drinks were distinct from traditional soft drinks and should be taxed accordingly. The high court examined the formulation of these beverages, considering their ingredients, manufacturing process, marketing, and labelling before arriving at its decision.

Implications for the Industry

This ruling is expected to provide significant relief to manufacturers of fruit pulp and juice-based carbonated drinks. The lower tax rate is likely to encourage further innovation and expansion within this segment of the beverage industry. By reducing the tax burden, manufacturers can offer these drinks at more competitive prices, potentially increasing consumer demand.

Additionally, the judgment sets a legal precedent that could influence future tax classifications of similar products. Other manufacturers like Varun Beverages Limited producing fruit-based beverages may now have grounds to seek reclassification of their products under the lower GST slab, leading to broader implications for the industry.

Consumer and Market Impact

For consumers, this decision may translate into more affordable pricing for fruit-based carbonated beverages. The reduced tax rate lowers the overall cost burden on manufacturers, which could be passed on to customers in the form of lower retail prices. This is especially relevant during the summer months when demand for refreshing fruit-based drinks increases significantly.

Furthermore, the ruling could prompt companies to introduce more fruit-based carbonated drinks, expanding choices available to consumers.

Conclusion

While this decision provides clarity for the taxation of fruit-based carbonated drinks, including those by X’SS Beverage, future legal challenges or policy changes could impact its long-term application. Tax authorities may revisit classifications as industry practices evolve, and further rulings may be needed to refine distinctions between beverage types.

Disclaimer: This blog has been written exclusively for educational purposes. The securities mentioned are only examples and not recommendations. This does not constitute a personal recommendation/investment advice. It does not aim to influence any individual or entity to make investment decisions. Recipients should conduct their own research and assessments to form an independent opinion about investment decisions.

Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing.